For almost two decades, RateBeer was not simply a ratings website. It was the place where much of craft culture as we know it today was built: the site where a Belgian Trappist beer could sell out because of one review, where unknown breweries became legends, and where thousands of fans around the world learned to distinguish a lambic from a barrel-aged stout.
This is its full story.
Who founded RateBeer and how it all began
RateBeer was born in May 2000, when the internet was still a territory under construction and craft beer was a very small niche outside the United States and Belgium.
Its original founder was Bill Buchanan, with a simple idea: to create a space where beer fans could freely exchange opinions and ratings. Soon after, Canadian beer writer Josh Oakes joined, sharing the goal of building a platform more plural and open than the ones that existed at the time.
But the decisive leap came in June 2001, when Joe Tucker entered the picture, a technologist based in Oregon - one of the leading states in the US craft scene - who completely restructured the design and usability of the website. Tucker removed the tedious alphabetical listings that forced users to browse for minutes to find a beer, and built a more intuitive architecture that made discovery much easier.
From that moment, RateBeer began to grow steadily.
The moment RateBeer became a global reference
If there is one date that defines RateBeer's peak, it is August 2006.
That summer, the platform rated Westvleteren 12, the Trappist beer brewed by the monks of St. Sixtus Abbey in Belgium, as the best beer in the world. The news spread through international media and caused something extraordinary: stocks of Westvleteren sold out almost immediately, and the monks, who brewed only to finance the maintenance of the abbey and sold under very restricted conditions, were overwhelmed by demand.
It was the first time a digital beer-rating platform showed real and direct impact on the market.
From then on, the RateBeer effect became something breweries and distributors took very seriously. Appearing at the top of its rankings could completely transform the international perception of a brewery. Names such as Russian River with Pliny the Elder, Hill Farmstead, Cantillon, 3 Fonteinen or The Alchemist with Heady Topper consolidated cult status partly thanks to the attention RateBeer generated.
The physical diplomas sent from Tucker's office came to hang proudly on the walls of bars and breweries around the world.
What role BeerAdvocate played before RateBeer
To understand RateBeer, you need to know its direct predecessor: BeerAdvocate.
In 1996, brothers Jason and Todd Alström founded BeerAdvocate in Boston with a similar idea: reviewing beers and creating community. Over time, they added forums and a rating system that made it one of the most respected beer communities on the internet, with both fans and industry professionals present.
In 2003, the Alströms began organising their own festivals, and in 2006 they launched a print magazine that reached more than 150,000 monthly readers, becoming the leading beer publication in the United States.
However, that expansion into events, print and journalism made BeerAdvocate lose focus on ratings and the global online community. That decision, together with its predominantly US orientation, left the path open for RateBeer first, and Untappd later, to take international digital leadership.
The AB InBev acquisition: the beginning of the end
The most controversial moment in RateBeer's history came in 2016, when ZX Ventures - the investment and innovation division of AB InBev, the world's largest industrial brewing group - acquired a significant stake in the platform.
The news leaked before the official announcement, which created even more discomfort among a community that, by definition, had built its identity around independent beer and resistance to big corporations.
As analyst Don Tse noted in a Forbes article after the closure: "Since then, many craft beer consumers, who normally like to avoid beer from large multinational corporations, stopped using the platform."
In February 2019, Tucker himself announced on the website forums that AB InBev had completed the full acquisition of RateBeer. In his statement, he defended the improvements the investment had brought: stronger infrastructure, faster loading, modernised forums and the creation of a smartphone app.
But for many users, trust had already been broken. The gradual migration to other platforms - especially Untappd - was already visible, and nothing in the official message managed to stop it.
Why Untappd won the battle
Untappd was not born with RateBeer's depth or historical archive, but it understood perfectly where digital consumer behaviour was heading.
While RateBeer focused on long reviews, technical databases and elaborate rankings, Untappd built a radically different experience:
- Instant check-ins from mobile, at the moment of drinking the beer
- Social component with friend following and real-time activity
- Integration with bars and taprooms, which could manage their menus directly in the app
- Simple interface adapted to fast and visual consumption
In the world of infinite scroll and notifications, RateBeer had stayed in another era. Its design, usage logic and target audience belonged to an internet that no longer existed.
According to Tucker himself in the closure statement published in December 2024, some users tried to acquire the platform before the final announcement. Conversations with AB InBev to transfer the content to a non-profit community were unsuccessful. Decades of ratings, reviews and collective knowledge accumulated by millions of users around the world ended, in the words of those who tried, "in the trash".
RateBeer's legacy in craft beer
Beyond the closure, RateBeer's impact on contemporary beer culture is undeniable.
The platform helped popularise styles that are now completely common in any craft beer shop: Imperial Stout, Double IPA, Sour Ales, modern Lambic, Barrel-Aged Stouts or New England IPA all had a global showcase on RateBeer when they were still rarities almost unknown outside their places of origin.
It was also a fundamental tool for small independent breweries to reach an international audience long before social networks existed. In many cases, a good position on RateBeer was the only way a craft brewery could become known outside its country.
And for years, its annual rankings were an essential reference for industry professionals, importers, distributors and advanced consumers around the world.
What alternatives exist today
The ecosystem for rating and discovering craft beer has changed a great deal since RateBeer's golden years. These are the most widely used platforms today:
Untappd is now the dominant global reference, with tens of millions of active users and a huge beer database. Its approach is more social and less technical than RateBeer's, but it is the most complete option for today's consumer.
BeerAdvocate remains active, especially in the US market, with a veteran community and detailed reviews.
Reddit - especially subreddits such as r/beertrade or r/craftbeer - has absorbed part of the more technical conversations and collecting culture that characterised RateBeer.
Instagram and TikTok have completely democratised the discovery of new beers, although at the cost of depth and historical archive.
Blogs and specialised communities remain a reference for fans looking for more than a check-in.
Conclusion
RateBeer was not just a ratings website. For more than a decade, it was the place where global craft beer culture was built online. It helped create legends, break geographical borders and prove that a well-argued review could move markets.
Its closure is not only the disappearance of a platform: it is the symbolic end of a way of understanding the online beer community - slower, more technical, deeper - that today's digital world has replaced with one that is faster, more visual and more ephemeral.
For an entire generation of fans, RateBeer was part of the story of how they learned to love craft beer. That legacy, even without a server, does not disappear.
Want to keep discovering craft beers from around the world? In our shop you will find a selection of the best craft beers, with delivery across Spain. [Explore our catalogue →]
